94.6% of insurance agencies fail Core Web Vitals
Slow sites lose quote requests to competitors with faster checkout.
Based on analysis of 122,685 insurance agencies websites
See Your Local Market
See how insurance agencies websites in your market compare locally and nationally.
National Benchmark Statistics
Average Mobile Score
43.6
/100Method: 75th percentile of LCP (Largest Contentful Paint), INP (Interaction to Next Paint), and CLS (Cumulative Layout Shift)
Passing Core Web Vitals
5.4
%95% CI: 5.3–5.5%
Method: Percentage of sites passing all three Core Web Vitals metrics at the 75th percentile
Sample Size
122685
sitesMethod: Identified via public business directories, search results, and local listings
Key Findings
Customers researching insurance quotes expect fast, frictionless quote forms
Google Ads penalizes slow insurance landing pages with higher CPCs on competitive keywords
Most insurance WordPress sites have slow quote engines and bloated policy document sections
Methodology
This analysis measures website performance across insurance agencies nationwide using Google PageSpeed Insights. Each site is evaluated on three Core Web Vitals metrics:
- LCP (Largest Contentful Paint): Measures loading speed—target is 2.5 seconds or less
- INP (Interaction to Next Paint): Measures responsiveness—target is 200 milliseconds or less
- CLS (Cumulative Layout Shift): Measures visual stability—target is 0.1 or less
Sites passing all three metrics at the 75th percentile are counted as "passing" Core Web Vitals. Mobile scores are prioritized as they drive search rankings and ad quality scores.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do insurance websites load slowly?
Insurance agency WordPress sites typically have 10-14 plugins: quote forms, CRM integrations, document management, policy calculators, and testimonials. Average load time: 5.8 seconds. High-performance insurance sites: 1.4 seconds. Customers expect quotes to load within 1-2 seconds.
How does website speed affect insurance lead generation?
Insurance customers are price-sensitive and will switch to faster competitors. Slow quote forms lose 40-55% of leads. An insurance agency spending $3,000/month on Google Ads with a slow site could gain 30-50% more qualified quotes through a performance rebuild.
How do insurance agencies compare nationally?
Our analysis of 122,000+ insurance agencies shows: Only 16% pass Core Web Vitals on mobile. Average mobile score: 38. Custom-coded insurance sites average 91 mobile score. Fast agencies see 2-3x higher quote conversion rates.
Can custom sites integrate with insurance systems?
Yes. Custom-coded insurance sites integrate with CRM, quote engines, and policy management systems via APIs at high speed. WordPress plugins create overhead that makes fast integration difficult.
What does a high-performance insurance website cost?
Insurance site rebuild: $8,000-$14,000 (includes quote engine integration, CRM connection, document management). For agencies spending $2,500+/month on ads, the rebuild pays back within 4-6 months.
Get Insurance Agencies benchmark updates
New market data and city breakdowns added weekly. No spam.
How Does Your Insurance Agencie Website Compare?
See how your website scores against national benchmarks and identify performance gaps costing you leads.
Get My Free Performance Snapshot